Comparing Brass, Bronze, and Copper: Understanding Their Difference

Explore the distinctive properties and applications of copper, brass, and bronze, three crucial metals in precision machining and industry.

Table of Contents

The overview of copper

copper color
copper color

The grades of Copper

Copper is a well-known metal recognized for its conductivity and versatility, and it is obtainable in various grades. These ranges of copper are commonly chosen based on their suitability to various engineering needs, which may range from simple parts to complicated systems. Here are some alloys of copper that are most often used:

  • Alloy 101: The oxygen-free attribute of this grade enhances its electrical conductivity and flexibility, making it suitable for applications demanding these characteristics, such as advanced electronics and precision engineering works.
  • Alloy 110 (Electrolytic Copper): It has the highest electrical and thermal conductivities among copper grades and impressive formability and ductility. It is frequently employed in electric systems where efficiency must be maintained.
  • Alloy 122: This alloy shares many similarities with Alloy 110; however, it differs in terms of enhanced machinability, weldability, and malleability. These properties make it ideal for plumbing fittings and industrial applications where easy fabrication is essential.
  • Alloy 145 (Tellurium Copper): With about 0.7% tellurium content, this copper alloy is known for its excellent machineability and improved thermal and electrical conductivity in cases requiring high conductance but complex machining operations.

The applications of copper

Due to its exceptional mechanical qualities, copper finds use in many industries as diverse as those requiring durability, corrosion resistance, or conduction abilities. Some key areas that make use of this metal include;

  • Heat Sinks and Heat Exchangers: Copper’s superior thermal conductivity makes it a preferred choice for heat sinks or exchangers. Essential components in computer central processing units (CPUs) up to large plants that require cooling or heating systems increase efficiency by preventing overheating.
  • Architectural Components: For builders and architects alike, copper’s natural appeal and long life are enchanting. It is extensively employed in roofing, facades, and decorative elements to provide additional aesthetics and structural integrity.
  • Electric Motors: Copper is better than other metals when manufacturing electric motors because of its high electrical conductivity. This means that motors work efficiently with minimum energy loss.
  • Telecommunication Components: In the telecommunication industry, copper produces cables, wires, and other vital components that transmit signals reliably.
  • Anti-biofouling Components in Submarines: Copper has antibacterial properties that make it ideal for submarine components where biofouling occurs. It helps preserve the functionality and operationality of such parts even when subjected to harsh marine conditions.

The overview of bronze

bronze colour
bronze colour

The grades of bronze

Different compositions result in the classification of bronze alloys into grades of varying versatility and strength. Two commonly used bronze grades include;

  • Alloy 932: This high-leaded tin bronze is mainly used to fabricate bushings and washers. It has a composition designed to facilitate ease of machining and durability.
  • Alloy 954: Named aluminum bronze, this alloy possesses aluminum, which gives it strong toughness. Because of its strength, it is commonly applied in robust support requirements such as industrial machinery and equipment installations.

Applications for Bronze

The properties that accompany alloys enable bronze to be applicable across various fields. Here are some typical applications of bronze:

  • Bearings and Bushings: This ranks among the most widespread uses of bronze. Due to its superior wear resistance and immunity against corrosion, bronze is often used to produce bearings and bushings found in automobiles and industrial machinery.
  • Marine Equipment: The material properties exhibited by Bronze make it suitable for manufacturing marine equipment like ship fittings, propellers, offshore platforms, etc, due to its non-corrosive nature.
  • Sculpture Art: Artists use bronze more often when creating sculptures because they can easily mold and not break it easily. Some famous historical sculptures were made from bronze.
  • Petrochemical Equipment: In Oil & Chemical Industries, various equipment such as valves, pumps, or pipeline systems require good mechanical properties and aluminum/steel-clad copper strips or wires braided from tin-plated phosphor bronzes, etc., which are used by connectors/springs makers, higher corrosion resistance which high-strength bronzes can provide.
  • Electrical Connectors: Electrical conductive materials include titanium/tin/silver coated copper beryllium, aluminum/steel clad copper strips or wires braided from tin-plated phosphor bronzes, etc., which are used by connectors/springs makers, specifically those needing resistance towards oxidation.
  • Components of Transportation Vehicles’: Bearings for transmissions have been fabricated with heat-resistant/anti-corrosive/highly durable bronzes, just like many other critical components of planes and cars.

The overview of brass

brass color
brass color

Grades of Brass

Brass, a metal alloy mainly composed of copper and zinc, is well-known for its versatility and is grouped into various types according to the percentage composition of the constituent elements. These different grades modify the properties of this alloy to suit specific uses, specifically in precision engineering, construction, and marine.

  • 260 Alloy (Cartridge Brass): 260 Alloy has excellent cold working characteristics besides being extensively employed in making automobile components, fasteners, and ammunition. It offers durability to CNC prototype machining and part production fields.
  • 272 Alloy (Yellow Brass): With approximately 33% zinc content, 272 Alloy promotes weldability, making it highly valuable in industrial manufacturing where strong, dependable welds are critical.
  • 330 Alloy: This contains low lead levels; hence, it is readily machinable and best suited for cold-working applications. Due to its adaptability and corrosion resistance, it is used mainly as a plumbing or piping material.
  • 360 Alloy (Free-cutting Brass): The most utilized brass alloy, 360 Alloy has outstanding malleability and machinability, making it suitable for delicate work during soldering or brazing operations. It’s commonly used when manufacturing small complex parts like fittings, fasteners, and valves.
  • 385 Alloy (Architectural Brass): Its high strength-to-weight ratio makes it appropriate for constructional components within architectural frameworks where beauty and long-lastingness are crucial considerations.
  • 464 Alloy (Naval Brass): Designed mainly for harsh marine environments conditions, this corrosion-resistant brass alloy is cherished because it can withstand temperature changes as well as being compatible with various methods such as welding, soldering, or bending during metal works. Hence, naval hardware such as shipbuilding necessitates its use.
  • 353 Alloy (Clock Brass): Confirmedly known as an excellent machinable material, it is typically employed by the horology industry while constructing watch elements, which must be precise and reliable.

Applications for Brass

Brass is a highly versatile metal alloy, appreciated for its aesthetic qualities and functional characteristics that make it suitable for multiple custom applications. The unique golden hue of this material, which resembles gold, makes it more appealing for decorative purposes. In contrast, it can be easily worked and machined, making it ideal for precision-demanding tasks. Below are some significant areas where brass finds application:

  • Musical Instruments: Brass is preferred because its sound properties give rich and resonant notes.
  • Jewelry: It looks like gold, so it is popularly used to make various types of cheaper jewelry that still look good.
  • Plumbing Fittings: The strength and corrosion resistance properties of brass are perfect attributes for plumbing fittings, thus bringing durability and reliability to water supply systems.
  • Electronics and Electrical Terminals: For example, in the electronics industry, where high conductivity is necessary, brass is commonly employed in electrical terminals and connectors.
  • Door Trim – For architectural applications such as door trimmings or other fixtures requiring resilience and aesthetics, brass comes in handy.

Brass vs. bronze vs. copper: material comparison and analysis

Bronze vs. Brass vs. Copper

Composition of Elements

Among the three, copper is distinguished as the only natural metal. It is an element that occurs naturally as a (non-ferrous) metal and can be directly applied to many applicable manufacturing techniques. On the contrary, brass and bronze are alloys, not pure metals.

Brass mainly consists of alloyed copper and zinc. Additional elements such as lead, manganese, iron, silicon, and aluminum can enrich this composition for specific industrial applications. On the other hand, bronze consists primarily of copper and tin. For strength or durability, it can also have different constituents, including phosphorous, aluminum nickel, or zinc.

These metals’ elemental compositions underline their unique uses and characteristics; therefore, they are helpful in different ways to their nature. In other words, while copper is directly usable in various forms because it naturally occurs, brass and bronze alloys can give them tailor-made properties needed for different applications across industries.

Corrosion Resistance

Brass has better corrosion resistance than both copper and bronze. This makes it ideal for marine environments with high saltwater corrosion rates. Copper comes next, having good corrosion resistance from its protective coatings, whereas bronze tends to be less effective under severe marine conditions.

Brass has a lower resistance to corrosion than either bronze or copper when exposed to saline or wet surroundings.

In summary, bronze provides the highest level of corrosion resistance, followed by copper, with brass at the lowest level.

Weight

Bronze machined parts
Bronze machined parts

The weight difference between brass, bronze, and copper largely determines suitability. Comparing the weights of bronze and brass shows that these two metals weigh roughly the same, although in some cases, people may choose one over the other because it weighs less.

They have a density of 8720 kg/cu.m brass is lighter than any other metals in this group. Bronze ranges from 7400-8900 kg/cu.m thick, while copper, on its part, is 8930 kg/cu.m heavy.

The weight hierarchy: Copper> Bronze> Brass is significant for materials selection based on structural requirements and cost-effectiveness.

Hardness

Brass has a range of Brinell hardness from 55 to 73; this makes it a good choice for mechanical applications, including musical instruments, due to its sound properties. This is another way of saying that brass may exhibit different compositions to vary hardness.

Copper’s hardness is approximately 35 at the lower end, and it benefits from such softness in electrical and plumbing areas where malleability and conductivity are required. It is important to note that copper has a hardness of about 35 at the lower back, making it soft enough for electrical connections or pipes.

Of these metals, bronze can be considered the most complex material, ranging from 40-420 on the Brinell scale. It is brittle and durable; thus, it is ideal as a structural material, but it is still subject to fracturing.

Machinability

Precision CNC Turning and Milling Bronze Parts
Precision CNC Turning and Milling Bronze Parts

The machinability of bronze and copper tends to be at a different level than that associated with brass. Machining operations performed on copper exhibit better machinability, hence increased flexibility, enabling the smooth running of normal manufacturing operations. For many diverse industrial processes, adaptability is very essential here.

Contrarily, bronze is more rigid, reducing its suitability for various machining operations. Though toughened, some machining complications occur, leading to tool wear and operational inefficiency. However, machining brass is tricky compared to bronze or copper, making it the least machinable. Being not flexible enough or bending under stress, brass needs special techniques or tools to manage it effectively in machining dealings.

Weldability

There are variations between copper, bronze, and brass regarding their weldability. Oxygen-free or deoxidized copper demonstrates excellent weldability through TIG-MIG methods.

Softer brass alloys with low zinc content are more weldable. These include MIG, TIG, and silver soldering techniques.

Especially with a lead, bronze may be challenging because it tends to crack under pressure. Welding lead-free bronze grades is best done using the SWAM technique to reduce the possibility of cracking.

Durability

Among copper and brass, bronze is regarded as the most durable due to its low corrosion rate and negligible bending ability. Its strength and longevity distinguish it from other metals.

Copper also lasts long but is more flexible than bronze; hence, it does not get small cracks or scratches. It is built for durability yet is easy to use.

Brass, however, has many cracking points and erodes quickly, unlike any other material. In terms of durability, Bronze> Copper> Brass.

Melting point

As one of the softest metals available, brass melts at around 927ºC. This outstanding characteristic endears brass to detailed works involving metalwork. Conversely, casting intricate sculptures and components with ease are advantages that come with the slightly lower melting point (about 913ºC) of bronze.

With copper with a melting point of around 1085ºC, it lacks malleability, providing higher electrical conductivity and flexibility when used industrially. As such, copper’s higher melting point will ensure durability and efficiency, especially in electric cables and high-end utensils for cooking. Thus, copper is indispensable in industrial and culinary practices.

Strength (Yield and Tensile Strength)

Brass Machining Parts
Brass Machining Parts

Regarding metal strength among Brass vs. Bronze vs. Copper, there are significant differences in yield strengths as well as tensile strengths shown by each material here represented by their yield strength values: B=125-800 MPa Cu=95-124 MPa and C3=33 MPa, respectively, which should indicate clearly that this material is very durable. At the same time, B follows next since Cu has the most negligible value.

Bronze scores over 350-635MPa, making it suitable for fighting against metal fatigue. Brass has an ultimate tensile strength of 338-469 MPa, and copper is 210 MPa. Each material has its benefits for different projects requiring particular strengths.

Thermal and Electrical Conductivity

Regarding electrical conductance, copper leads with a perfect score of 100%, brass follows at about 28%, and bronze around 15%. Copper comes first because of its higher contents; hence, electrical applications follow this order: copper>brass>bronze.

The sequence here is Bronze>Copper>Brass as far as thermal conductivity is concerned since bronze performs better than others in this parameter by having a range of 229 to1440 BTU/hr-ft²-ºf; copper has only one value at 223 BTU/hr-ft²-ºf. In contrast, brass lies at the bottom with just one figure, which reads 64 BTU/hr-ft²-ºf. This helps users select materials for heat applications because some properties are associated with them.

How to choose the suitable material for your machining parts

General Usage

It is malleable and cost-effective, which makes brass the right choice for things like doorknobs and musical instruments, as it has a low friction coefficient. These uses can be either functional or decorative.

Saltwater corrosion resistance is the main reason bronze is superb in marine applications. This means that parts exposed to harsh marine conditions should be made of bronze.

Copper is chosen for food flasks and heaters because of its antibacterial properties that ensure safety in food-related applications.

Thus, selecting brass, bronze, or copper for machining parts involves evaluating specifics like environmental durability, health safety, and frequent handling. Each material suits these requirements with different advantages.

Degree of Flexibility

When choosing materials for machining parts, knowing the peculiarities of brass, bronze, and copper is crucial. Copper has high flexibility, conductance, and elasticity, making it suitable for electrical and thermal applications. Brass and bronze are highly machinable. For example, corrosion-resistant components can be produced from brass (copper-zinc alloy). Similarly, durable parts like bearings and bushings require metals such as bronze, known for their strength and wear resistance. Based on these attributes, opt for the most appropriate material for your project design.

Cost

When selecting suitable materials for machining parts, consider the cost and properties of brass and bronze; the considerable amount of zinc makes it less expensive, making it ideal for projects with good machinability and corrosion resistance, as well as copper.

The considerable amount of zinc makes it less expensive and ideal for projects with good machinability and corrosion resistance, such as electrical connectors or fancy objects.

Bronze costs more due to its incredible strength and superior corrosion resistance, making it quite applicable in ship propellers, including submerged bearings.

The most expensive copper has excellent electrical and heat conductivity, making this element ideal in various areas such as electrical wiring or electronic appliances whose performance must be optimal at all times.

Therefore, each one provides unique benefits when it comes to machining parts in such a way that you can match the particular material with the needs of your project.

Conclusion

Understanding the unique attributes of copper, brass, and bronze helps select the suitable material for specific applications, enhancing durability and efficiency.

Partner with us for expert guidance and superior machining solutions tailored to your project’s material needs.

ChansMachining

On-demand CNC Machining prototyping and parts with Custom Finishes and low volume manufacturing.

Share this article with your friends.

Get a help or information from us

Add Your Heading Text Here